Dependency cycle

[tcharding]

I wanted to see the dependency graph for BDK so I could see what order things need upgrading when we do a rust-bitcoin release. Here is what I came up with, it looks like there is a dependency cycle when considering the upgrade path (ie., the cycle only exists when considering dev-dependencies. How do you guys normally get around this?

electrsd -> bitcoin_slices -> bitcoin-test-data -> electrsd

EDIT: The line above is incorrect, it was accidentally using the (now removed) dependency graph of electrs not electrsd

Dependency graph for the bdk stack of crates

Dependencies controlled by either the BDK team or the rust-bitcoin team.

Includes crates by RCasatta:

• electrsd
• bitcoin-test-data
• bitcoin_slices

electrsd

electrsd v0.26.0
├── bitcoind v0.33.3
└── electrum-client v0.15.1

[build-dependencies]
└── bitcoin_hashes v0.12.0 (*)

bitcoin_slices

bitcoin_slices v0.7.0
├── bitcoin v0.31.0
└── bitcoin_hashes v0.13.0 (*)

[dev-dependencies]
├── bitcoin v0.31.0 (*)
├── bitcoin-test-data v0.2.0
└── hex_lit v0.1.1

bitcoin-test-data

bitcoin-test-data v0.2.0
[dev-dependencies]
└── electrsd v0.23.3

rust-esplora-client

esplora-client v0.6.0
├── bitcoin v0.30.2
└── bitcoin-internals v0.1.0

[dev-dependencies]
├── electrsd v0.24.0
└── electrum-client v0.16.0

rust-electrum-client

electrum-client v0.18.0
├── bitcoin v0.30.1
└── bitcoin-private v0.1.0

rust-hwi

hwi v0.7.0
├── bitcoin v0.30.2
└── miniscript v10.0.0

bdk

Crates

• bdk

bdk v1.0.0-alpha.2
├── bdk_chain v0.6.0
├── bip39 v1.2.0
├── bitcoin v0.30.1 ()
├── hwi v0.7.0
└── miniscript v10.0.0 ()

[dev-dependencies]
└── bdk_file_store v0.2.0

• chain

bdk_chain v0.6.0
├── bitcoin v0.30.1
└── miniscript v10.0.0

• file_store

bdk_file_store v0.2.0
└── bdk_chain v0.6.0

• electrum

bdk_electrum v0.4.0
├── bdk_chain
└── electrum-client v0.18.0

• esplora

bdk_esplora v0.4.0
├── bdk_chain v0.6.0
├── bitcoin v0.30.1 (*)
└── esplora-client v0.6.0

[dev-dependencies]
└── electrsd v0.25.0

• bitcoind_rpc

bdk_bitcoind_rpc v0.1.0
├── bdk_chain
├── bitcoin v0.30.1 (*)
└── bitcoincore-rpc v0.17.0

[dev-dependencies]
└── bitcoind v0.33.2

Example crates

• example_cli

• example electrum

• example_esplora

• example_bitcoind_rpc_polling

• wallet_electrum

• wallet_esplora_blocking

• wallet_esplora_async

Nursery

• tmp_plan

• coin_select

[tcharding]

In case you want to see the one for the rust-bitcoin crates, its here: rust-bitcoin/rust-bitcoin#2216

[apoelstra]

dev-dependencies are only compiled when testing a particular crate. You never compile the dev-dependencies of your dependencies.

[tcharding]

I was wrong, there is no cycle but not for the reason you stated. I had the graph for electrs not electrsd - that is not the first time I've mixed those two crates up.

[tcharding]

I was wrong, closing. I've updated the original post to use the dependency graph of electrsd